IELTS Writing Task 2 – Harsher Punishments to Reduce Crime
📝 Ideas with Explanation
✅ Arguments in Favor of Harsher Punishments (Why It Is Effective)
1️⃣ Acts as a Strong Deterrent – Strict punishments instill fear, discouraging potential criminals from engaging in illegal activities.
🔹 Example: Countries with the death penalty for serious crimes, such as Singapore, have lower crime rates compared to nations with lenient laws.
2️⃣ Ensures Justice for Victims – Severe punishments reinforce the idea that justice is served, giving victims and their families a sense of closure.
🔹 Example: Life imprisonment for murder cases ensures that dangerous criminals do not threaten society again.
3️⃣ Reduces Repeat Offenses – Criminals who face long-term imprisonment or strict penalties are less likely to re-offend.
🔹 Example: Studies show that offenders sentenced to harsher punishments have lower chances of committing crimes again.
✅ Arguments Against Harsher Punishments (Why It Is Not the Best Solution)
1️⃣ Does Not Address the Root Causes of Crime – Poverty, lack of education, and unemployment contribute to criminal behavior, and punishment alone does not solve these issues.
🔹 Example: Scandinavian countries focus on rehabilitation rather than harsh punishments, resulting in lower crime rates.
2️⃣ Risk of Wrongful Convictions – Strict laws may lead to unjust punishments, especially in cases where innocent individuals are wrongly accused.
🔹 Example: Some cases in the U.S. have seen prisoners released after years of imprisonment due to new evidence proving their innocence.
3️⃣ Rehabilitation is More Effective – Instead of punishment, offering educational and employment opportunities to offenders can help them reintegrate into society.
🔹 Example: Norway’s prison system focuses on rehabilitation, and it has one of the lowest re-offending rates in the world.
📌 Sample Answer
Introduction (Paraphrased Using Passive Voice):
It can be observed that stricter punishments are considered by some to be the most effective method of reducing crime. While harsh penalties may serve as a deterrent, others argue that addressing the root causes of criminal behavior is a better long-term solution. This essay will discuss both perspectives before presenting my opinion.
Body Paragraph 1 – Harsher Punishments as a Crime Deterrent
Commencing with the argument in favor of severe punishments, imposing strict legal consequences creates fear among potential criminals. When individuals realize that crimes such as robbery or murder could lead to long-term imprisonment or even capital punishment, they may think twice before engaging in illegal activities. For example, countries with strict laws, such as Singapore, have significantly lower crime rates compared to nations with lenient judicial systems. Moreover, harsher penalties ensure justice for victims and reduce the likelihood of repeat offenses. Thus, implementing strict punishments can play a crucial role in maintaining law and order.
Body Paragraph 2 – Why Harsh Punishments Alone Are Not Enough
On the other hand, focusing solely on punishment does not address the underlying causes of crime. Many offenses stem from social issues such as poverty, unemployment, and lack of education. For instance, Scandinavian countries have successfully reduced crime rates by focusing on rehabilitation programs rather than extreme punishments. Additionally, strict laws increase the risk of wrongful convictions, potentially punishing innocent individuals. Therefore, a balanced approach that combines fair legal consequences with social reforms is more effective in the long run.
Conclusion:
To conclude, while harsher punishments can deter criminals and reinforce justice, they do not address the root causes of crime. In my opinion, governments should implement a combination of strict laws and rehabilitation programs to ensure long-term crime reduction. Therefore, focusing on both punishment and preventive measures is the key to a safer society.
📌 Vocabulary for a High Band Score
✅ Crime & Punishment Vocabulary:
- Legal consequences
- Capital punishment
- Deterrent effect
- Judicial system
- Rehabilitation programs
- Law enforcement
✅ Advanced Linkers & Phrases:
- Commencing with the argument in favor of…
- On the other hand, focusing solely on punishment does not…
- A clear example of this is…
- Thus, implementing strict punishments can…
- To conclude, while harsher punishments can deter criminals…